Strategy or Identity: The Real Question Behind Your Business

Every morning, I put on an audiobook from a Spotify channel called The Millionaire Library, which I'd genuinely encourage you to check out.

Small wink here: I don't know if listening to audiobooks on philosophy and mindset will make me a millionaire, and that's not really the point anyway, even if the channel's name is a bit of a hook. The point is feeding your mind through different channels, different mediums, and this one happens to be doing it for me right now.

I listen while getting ready, then again in the car, on my way to the office. Some passages are dense enough that I have to hit pause, mid-traffic, to note an idea on my phone before I lose it. That happened again last week, stopped at a red light, deep into The Secret Code of Solomon, in the chapter about the death of the ego and the birth of the king. I typed three words, fast, before the light turned green: Strategy vs Identity.

It's been months since I last posted here. Life happened. I don't put myself under an editorial calendar's pressure. I need to be in a particular headspace to write, to live things, to listen to things, and sometimes to do nothing at all, just to finally hear myself think. And then share what I hope will actually be useful to you.

So here's what's been on my mind lately, and the more I sit with it, the more I think it's the blind spot for most people who set out to build something.

Give the same strategy to two different people. Same plan, same steps, same tools. You'll get two different results. Sometimes very different. The strategy didn't change, the person executing it did. Strategy is what you do. Identity is who you're becoming while you do it. And most of us spend an enormous amount of energy refining the first while completely neglecting the second.

There's a sneakier version of this problem too, and I think a lot of us will recognize it. It's not just that we neglect identity, we sometimes use strategy to hide from it, without even realizing it. We chase the perfect strategy. The plan with no room for error. The ideal positioning, the ideal moment to launch. We tweak, we rework, we push it back another week, "just to refine it a bit more."

Except that chase for perfection often becomes a hiding place. As long as the plan isn't perfect, you don't have to run it yet. And as long as you don't run it, you can't fail. You're protected by the preparation itself. Strategic perfectionism is sometimes just fear of failure wearing the costume of rigor. And by pushing the deadline again and again, you still end up facing exactly what you were trying to avoid: either failure, because you launched too late, worn out from waiting, or the fear itself, untouched, never confronted, just postponed one more time.

That played out again just last week. A client came to me for help launching a project that had been sitting in limbo for over a year. Listening to her, I quickly realized the problem wasn't structural, and it wasn't strategic either. She'd asked for input from a dozen different people, exhausted every competitor's Pinterest board and Instagram page, and collected close to a hundred quotes, I'm barely exaggerating. She also kept bringing up her competitors, not to benchmark them, but over things far more trivial than I'll get into here. Once I'd taken it all in, it was clear the real problem wasn't the plan. It was her identity, her actual purpose, her emotional fragility, her fear.

There's another shift, quieter still, and this one hits closer to home for me personally. We start defining ourselves by what we produce. Our usefulness, our performance, our output become the measure of our worth. And the question of who we actually are, apart from what we accomplish, slides into the background. It's an easy slope to slide down, especially in entrepreneurship. You measure your week in checked-off tasks, your month in revenue, your worth against what everyone else seems to be producing. And one day, without quite noticing how it happened, you no longer know who you are on the days you produce nothing.

But the identity that actually holds over time isn't the one you rent out to your productivity. It's the one that's still there on a day when nothing got done. An identity borrowed from performance collapses the moment you're forced to stop, an illness, a slow season, a failure. An identity you've actually claimed survives those moments, because the person behind it doesn't need output to exist.

And then there's the question of what you're really chasing. A lot of people pursue success through accumulation. More revenue, more clients, more visible recognition. Chased on its own, that pursuit often pulls you further from the real goal instead of closer to it. What I hear, episode after episode, from people who've genuinely succeeded, in any field, is never "I wanted to accumulate." It's "I wanted to create," "I wanted to build something that lasts," "I wanted to pass something on." Wealth, when it shows up, tends to be a consequence of that pursuit. Rarely the other way around.

And this isn't unique to business, by the way. That's exactly why this blog is called Beyond Business. The same mechanism plays out in pretty much every area of life. The diet you abandon after two weeks, not because it was a bad plan, but because you still see yourself as someone without discipline. The relationship you repeat, in a different shape, with a different person, because what you haven't actually changed isn't the partner, it's the story you tell yourself about what you deserve. The habit you can never quite make stick, despite the best method out there, because deep down, you've never seen yourself as someone who keeps it.

Strategy just goes by different names depending on the arena. Marketing plan, workout program, decluttering method, life discipline. But the principle stays the same: it never takes root until it's carried by an identity that already matches it, even a little.

All of this converges on the same conclusion, I think. A strategy rarely collapses because it was flawed on paper. It collapses because the person meant to carry it out hadn't yet become the person who could, or because it was serving a goal that was never the right one to begin with. Strategy can't outgrow the identity carrying it. And however necessary it is, it stays useless without a strong, claimed identity behind it.

That doesn't mean ditching strategy, it's still essential, whether for a product launch or a New Year's resolution. But before asking "what's the right method," two questions deserve to come first, and they apply to business just as much as to everything else. What version of me does this goal actually require? And am I trying to create and build something, or am I only trying to accumulate?

Business isn't built by tactics alone. It's also built by working on who you're becoming, at the same time as what you're doing.

What strategy have you put off lately, not because it wasn't ready, but because you weren't ready to run it yet? Maybe a launch, a career change, a breakup you need to face, a habit you can't seem to keep, or a conversation you've been avoiding for too long. Tell me in the comments. And if something you've been listening to or reading lately has stayed with you the way this one stayed with me, share that too. That's exactly what this blog is for.

Follow Beyond Business by M for more content that goes beyond business: strategy, leadership, and everything that gets built in you while you build your work.